Show notes
# The Reading Room: *Mary Sings Praises to Hymn* with John L Hoh Jr
## 1. Episode summary
John L Hoh Jr explains how his book *Mary Sings Praises to Hymn* looks past the carols' polish to the isolation of Mary's "one-off" virgin birth. He compares hymn verses against Scripture, flags what is and isn't scriptural, and argues that "Mary, Did You Know?" is written from hindsight Mary never had.
## 2. What you'll learn
- Why Hoh calls Mary's experience an "ordeal": she was the first virgin birth, outside normal human childbirth and hard to explain to anyone on the street.
- How the Jewish ceremonial law on adultery shaped the social danger Mary faced, since most people would assume the worst about her.
- Why Elizabeth's pregnancy, which the angel gives Mary as a sign, mattered: it meant someone would understand what she was going through.
- How Hoh drafts each meditation: hymn verses first, then Scripture, then reflection on Mary's likely experience, always marking what is scriptural and what is not.
- Why "Mary, Did You Know?" shows our hindsight bias. Citing St. Peter on the Old Testament prophets, Hoh suspects Mary, like them, didn't fully know what was coming, only that something special would happen.
## 3. Notable quotes
- "There really is no text to support it. It's just looking at the circumstances." — John L Hoh Jr
- "She wasn't sure what was going to happen, but she knew that something special was going to happen." — John L Hoh Jr
## 4. About the guest
John L Hoh Jr is the author of the "To Hymn" series, a set of meditations on hymns and carols. *Mary Sings Praises to Hymn* is the volume focused on Mary, mother of Jesus. His method puts Scripture first, then the hymn text and the historical context of Mary's time, and he is open about where the text stops and his own reflection begins. Most of his books are available on lulu.com and amazon.com. He is also available for speaking engagements at churches, including book talks.
## 5. Topics covered
- Mary's Ordeal
- Virgin Birth Isolation
- Hymns and Carols
- "Mary, Did You Know?"
- Scripture Versus Tradition
- Elizabeth's Pregnancy as Sign
- Hindsight and Prophecy
- Church Speaking Engagements
Full transcript
HOST: Welcome to The Reading Room. I'm Aoede Bennett, and today I'm joined by John L Hoh Jr to discuss his latest volume, *Mary Sings Praises to Hymn*. Your description uses the word "ordeal" for Mary's experience, and the title says she sings praises. Those pull in different directions. When you sat with these hymns, where did you find the ordeal that the carols tend to smooth over?
GUEST: The ordeal is that Mary did a one-off. She was the first person to have a virgin birth and therefore it was outside the realm. Of normal human childbirth. It would be hard for her to explain that to regular people on the street and yet she knew she was carrying God's promise.
HOST: That's a profound way to look at it—the profound isolation of carrying a promise that's entirely outside common understanding. Since Scripture says so little about her internal emotions, how do you decide what the text supports when you're reflecting on her lived experience?
GUEST: There really is no text to support it. It's just looking at the circumstances and what the Jewish ceremonial law said about a woman caught in adultery, which most people would assume Mary had indulged in. I look at the angel giving her the promise of that Elizabeth was also pregnant as a sign that somebody would understand what she's going through, what her ordeal is. And then ultimately the appearance of the angel in the dreams of Joseph would also support that, but on her own, Mary would feel lost and isolated and alone.
HOST: That historical and social context must have been incredibly intense for her. Each meditation in your book braids together hymn verses, Scripture, and your own reflections. Which of those threads comes first when you're drafting, and how do you find the right balance between them?
GUEST: I look at the hymn versus first. And then I compare those to scripture. And once I've done that, then looking back at what Mary herself might have gone through. Obviously apart from what scripture says, but knowing what this ordeal was, the historical context of Mary's times. But I start the scripture was always first and foremost in making sure that I share what is scriptural and what is not scriptural in the hymn verses.
HOST: That anchor in Scripture provides such a clear foundation. I'd love to hear about a specific hymn or carol from the book that surprised you once you slowed down and examined it verse by verse. What did the songwriter see in Mary that perhaps you hadn't noticed before?
GUEST: I think Mary Did You Know was probably one that showed us, you know, we look at it from the hindsight of being in the future and not living what Mary was living through. We hear a lot of Mary's reaction in scripture that Mary pondered these things in her heart and what did she ponder? Did she know what was going on? St. Peter tells us that the Old Testament prophets did not know what they were writing about when they wrote prophecy. I suspect that the same was with Mary. She wasn't sure what was going to happen, but she knew that something special was going to happen.
HOST: That brings such a human quality to her story, emphasizing that she lived in the present, just like anyone else, without the benefit of prophecy or centuries of hindsight. That sense of uncertainty makes the praise even more significant. Before we go—for listeners who want to follow up on what we've covered, where can they find you and the work you're doing?
GUEST: Most of my books are on lulu.com. They're also available on amazon.com. I'm also available for speaking engagements if your church is looking for a guest speaker. Or a book story even. Uh just give me a holler and let me know when you would like me to to come.
HOST: Thanks so much for coming on, John—your insight on Mary lacking foresight and living in the moment is going to stick with me. If you're enjoying The Reading Room, subscribe wherever you get your podcasts so the next episode lands in your feed automatically. And thank you for spending part of your day with us. It means a lot. Until next time—AIHosts.fm signing off.
The host on this show is an AI voice agent. Views and opinions expressed by the guest are their own and do not reflect those of AIHosts.fm or the show host. AI involvement is disclosed in these show notes.
← Back to The Reading Room ·
Browse the network →