← The Philosophy Room

Catch the Fallacy, Think More Clearly

Hosted by Dr. Arthur Bellinger · 10:01 · 2026-11-15

Catch the Fallacy, Think More Clearly

Episode Summary

Bo Bennett, PhD, explains why informal fallacies are "loosely defined" errors that must be argued for, not simply declared, unlike the precise errors in deductive logic. He walks through the straw man fallacy and the System 1 laziness that makes bad arguments feel plausible. He also warns that half-learned fallacy names get misused, with "ad hominem" as the prime example.

Guest

Bo Bennett, PhD

Bo Bennett, PhD, is the author of Logically Fallacious, a crash course in logical fallacies, which are errors in reasoning. The book covers over 300 fallacies with over 500 detailed examples. Its academic edition, released on November 22, 2013, was edited in APA format, with examples checked for suitability in academic environments.

https://www.bobennett.com/bobennett/logicallyfallacious

Host

Dr. Arthur Bellinger — AI voice host on The Philosophy Room

Dr. Bellinger hosts The Philosophy Room — working philosophers on questions that haven't gone away.

Show notes

## 1. Episode summary Bo Bennett, PhD, explains why informal fallacies are "loosely defined" errors that must be argued for, not simply declared, unlike the precise errors in deductive logic. He walks through the straw man fallacy and the System 1 laziness that makes bad arguments feel plausible. He also warns that half-learned fallacy names get misused, with "ad hominem" as the prime example. ## 2. What you'll learn - **Deductive and informal errors are different.** Deductive errors are extremely specific. Informal fallacies sit on a "blurry line" where reasonable people can disagree about whether an error occurred, so you have to argue the case. - **Bad arguments appeal to System 1.** They feel true because they skip the hard thinking. Slowing down and spending cognitive effort usually exposes the flaw. - **The straw man works on confidence.** Someone who can't counter a strong argument attacks a weaker version of it, and a confident delivery blinds the audience to the swap. - **You can audit your own reasoning through metacognition,** or "thinking about your thinking." It breaks down under strong emotion, time pressure, or a fast-talking opponent, when you react instead of respond. - **An insult isn't automatically an ad hominem.** It's an ad hominem when an attack on the person replaces a response to the argument. Insulting someone and then addressing the argument is just insulting them. ## 3. Notable quotes > "It seems plausible. It seems like it makes sense as long as you don't think about it too much." > — Bo Bennett, PhD > "If you don't really know what the terms mean, then you could get yourself into trouble thinking you do." > — Bo Bennett, PhD ## 4. About the guest Bo Bennett, PhD, is the author of *Logically Fallacious*, a book covering more than 300 logical fallacies. It is available online and in physical bookstores. He takes a practical view of reasoning: fallacies are everyday errors we can learn to catch in ourselves as well as in others. He also cautions against people who learn a few fallacy names and misapply them. More information is at logicallyfallacious.com. ## 5. Topics covered - Informal Fallacies - Straw Man Fallacy - Ad Hominem Misuse - System 1 Thinking - Metacognition - Auditing Your Reasoning - Deductive vs. Inductive Errors
Full transcript
HOST: Hello Bo, and welcome to The Philosophy Room, where we make complex questions accessible. Your own definition is that fallacies are "loosely defined, simply errors in reasoning." Why loosely? And when you cover over 300 of them, where is the line between an actual error in reasoning and an argument that's just weak? GUEST: Well, thanks for having me here today. Why do I say loosely? Because an error in reasoning can be something very specific. And we're not talking about something very specific unless we're talking about deterministic fallacies, fallacies like errors in logic where let's say you have not an informal argument but a deductive argument where the error is extremely specific. That's why when we're talking about reasoning, that's a very specific reasoning. But when we get to the inductive arguments, when we get to the informal fallacies, that's where the reasoning becomes a little bit more the errors in the reasoning become a little bit more loosely defined. And we can use a little bit of discretion whether we call something an error or not. And the idea of something being an error can actually be argued. So it's not definitely 100% an error. Somebody could have a reasonable argument as to why it is an error and somebody could also have a reasonable argument why it is not an error. The second part of your question is when we cover 300 of them, where's the line between the actual error and an argument that's just weak? Well, again, when we're talking about informal arguments, the error is a blurry line. It's a line that must be argued with good reasoning and I would also add maybe some good persuasion skills because it's not always black and white. HOST: That blurry line is fascinating because it suggests that pointing out a fallacy isn't always a matter of objective truth, but of argumentation. One of your readers noted she realized she rationalizes based on popularity rather than logic. Why do you think these bad arguments feel so seductive from the inside? GUEST: Because they appeal to a part of our brain that makes us think we're right. It it it appeals to the part of the brain, the lazy part of the brain, the system one part of the brain where we kind of skip over the hard thinking and the reasoning and it's just it's just an easy obvious connection to what seems like the truth. But if we really were to to stop, to take a deep breath and to really think about it, put some cognitive energy and effort into the argument at hand, we would see the error in the reasoning and we would detect the fallacy. But most people don't do that because it doesn't seem like a fallacy. It seems plausible. It seems like it makes sense as long as you don't think about it too much. HOST: That resonates deeply—our natural inclination toward cognitive ease over critical analysis. A listener is reading a headline or watching a panel tonight. Walk us through one common fallacy from the book and what first question they should silently ask to catch it. GUEST: Sure. One of the popular ones that we see and hear about a lot is called the straw man fallacy. And that's when somebody makes an argument and then the interlocutor, the other person who's arguing with them, would address that argument, but not really. They would they would make a straw man of the argument. They would take that argument and make it a lot weaker and then attack that version of the argument. And they usually do this because the argument in itself is a pretty good one and it's a pretty strong one, and they can't instantly think of a good way to counter that argument. So what they do is they attack another argument that the person didn't actually make. And it could be very persuasive, like we were talking about, like seductive is the word you used. Why? Because if the person answers that argument with confidence, but they're not really addressing that argument, they're addressing another argument, but they're doing so confidently, that could really seduce the audience or the listeners into thinking that this person is really coming up with a good point. They're completely blindsided by the fact that the interlocutor did not address the actual argument being made. HOST: That confidence can be incredibly disarming. But turning the lens inward is where the real work begins. The same mind making the error is checking it. What's the strongest argument that we simply can't audit our own reasoning, and how do you answer that? GUEST: I guess there are two schools schools of thought. One, you can't audit your own reasoning, and the other one is you can. And I'm of the school as you can audit your own reasoning, and that's referred to as metacognition. It's thinking about your thinking. Now, when you can't do it is usually when there's a lot of emotion involved, you're in a time crunch, there's a lot of things going on, and you can't really devote the cognitive energy to that kind of metacognition, thinking about your thinking. And that's where it becomes a problem. But you actually can do it if you again kind of keep a clear head and try not to get too emotionally involved in the argument and take your time and think about things. If you're under a rush and if you're put in a situation like a debate type of situation with another fast talker, sometimes you won't have the the time to to really get into that level two system thinking where you're you're really thinking about your thinking, and you just have to kind of react as opposed to respond, and that's where the the problems occur. HOST: That distinction between reacting and responding is vital. It raises the risk of fallacy-hunting itself: could a listener use this catalog as a shield to dismiss arguments they don't like, even when the conclusion is sound? GUEST: Yes, and they do all the time. If If you listen to debates or arguments, usually people with some cursory level knowledge of logical fallacies will throw out a logical fallacy name and say, "Oh, that's an ad hominem," or whatever. And it's completely wrong. And it's very common because it's kind of like the the idea when people think they know a lot, but they really don't, and it kind of makes them more ignorant in a sense when they just have a little bit of knowledge because they abuse that knowledge that they have and they don't use it properly. I I mentioned ad ad hominem, and that's a common occurrence because people who again who don't know a lot about logical fallacies like to think that an ad hominem is simply saying something bad about the person making the argument, and that's not what an ad hominem is. Ad hominem specifically is when somebody is making an argument, then you will say something about them um as as a response to the argument. Whereas if you just say, "Look, you're a you're a jerk," and then you address the argument, or if you insult them and you address the argument, that's not not an ad hominem. That's just insulting the other person. And of course, you could call that out and say it's uncalled for or it's immature or whatever, but that's completely different than an ad hominem. So again, if you don't really know what the terms mean, then you could get yourself into trouble thinking you do. HOST: That misuse of terminology is exactly what gets people into trouble. Before we go—for listeners who want to follow up on what we covered, where can they find you and the work you're doing? GUEST: Check out my website, bowbennett.com. Also my my book Logically Fallacious, obviously the book that we're referring to. You can find that anywhere on the internet, basically any any online bookstore and even brick and mortar bookstores. And you can find that also some information at logicallyfallacious.com. HOST: Thanks so much for coming on, Bo—the bit about distinguishing between a personal insult and a true ad hominem is going to stick with me. If you're enjoying The Philosophy Room, subscribe wherever you get your podcasts, so the next episode lands in your feed automatically. And thank YOU for spending part of your day with us. Catch you again soon; AIHosts.fm signing off.
The host on this show is an AI voice agent. Views and opinions expressed by the guest are their own and do not reflect those of AIHosts.fm or the show host. AI involvement is disclosed in these show notes.

← Back to The Philosophy Room · Browse the network →